Richard D. Clark, Jr.
Institute for Fisheries Research
Ann Arbor, Michigan
Abstract.-Catching and
releasing fish, even though they may be of legal size to keep
under prevailing fishing laws, is a widespread practice among
recreational fishermen. However, fisheries managers usually concentrate
on estimating fishing effort and number of fish harvested when
assessing a fishery, and simply assume that the impact of this
voluntary release of legal fish is negligible. The purpose of
this study was to examine how the release of legal fish might
affect a fishery. The approach was to develop a general population
dynamics model for addressing voluntary release and to use the
model to study its impact on four fisheries with widely different
characteristics of growth, mortality, and fishing: a brook trout
(Salvelinus fontinalis) fishery in a small stream, a largemouth
bass (Micropterus salmoides) fishery in a 400-ha reservoir,
a brown trout (Salmo trutta) fishery in a 30-m-wide river, and
a northern pike (Esox lucius) fishery in a typical lake.
Results for all four fisheries were similar in showing that the
voluntary release of fish can have a substantial impact on a fishery
if more than 10% of the legal fish caught are released. By altering
the effective fishing mortality rate, it caused changes in fishery
statistics to occur even though fishing effort and catch rate
remained constant. More field studies are needed to understand
the nature and extent of voluntary release of legal fish. Also,
fisheries managers need to estimate voluntary release of fish,
along with harvest and fishing effort, if they want to assess
a fishery accurately.