Raymond J. Haak
School of Natural Resources
University of Michigan
Ann Arbor, Michigan
Abstract.-In Saginaw Bay,
Lake Huron a higher catch per unit effort of channel catfish Ictalurus
punctatus in recent years has prompted commercial fishermen
to request the Michigan Department of Natural Resources to allow
them to increase their fishing effort. Previous studies on the
potential for increasing commercial harvest were incomplete or
are dated, so a new study was needed. Of 2,460 channel catfish
tagged in the Wild Fowl Bay area of Saginaw Bay in 1985, 277 tags were
returned by sport and commercial fishermen. A catch curve constructed
using data collected by sampling catfish from commercial trap
nets in three management grids in the bay revealed that instantaneous
total mortality rate for catfish in Saginaw Bay was 0.45, down
from 0.67 in 1971 and 1981. An instantaneous fishing mortality
rate of 0.26 and an instantaneous natural mortality rate of 0.19
were determined by partitioning the instantaneous total mortality
rate using tag returns. A commercial reporting rate of 45% was
determined by sampling the commercial catch for unreported tagged
fish. Comparison of mean backcalculated lengths at age with previous
studies revealed a decline in growth rate of catfish. A dynamic
pool model indicated commercial fishing effort could be increased
to obtain greater yields. Greatest increases in yield could be
achieved by increasing both the commercial size limit and effort.
Sensitivity analysis indicated that instantaneous total mortality
rate, commercial reporting rate, and von Bertalanffy growth parameters
were most important in determining the levels of commercial fishing
effort and commercial size limit to maxmize yield. Increasing
the commercial size limit to 406.4 mm (16 in) was recommended
to increase total, commercial, and sport yield per 1000 recruits,
2.6%, 0.6%, and 9.1%, respectively.