Michigan Department of Natural Resources
Fisheries Research Report No. 1963, 1989

Hooking Mortality of Trophy-Sized Wild Brook Trout Caught on Artificial Lures


Andrew J. Nuhfer and Gaylord R. Alexander

Hunt Creek Fisheries Research Station
Lewiston, Michigan


Abstract.-The average hooking mortality per capture event for 630 trophy-sized wild brook trout (mean total length 33.9 cm) caught on five hardware lures was 4.3% during the first 48 hours after capture. Mortality was 8.3% for trout caught on Mepps spinners and Cleo spoons equipped with a treble pointed hook whereas fish caught on the same lures with a single-pointed hook died at a significantly lower rate of 2.4% per hooking event (P < 0.05). There was no mortality among 126 trout caught with Rapala lures rigged with two treble hooks. We believe that the differences in mortality of trout caught with different lures are due primarily to differences in the frequency and extent of damage to the gill arches and esophagus area. Certain lures were more likely to be engulfed deeply, particularly by larger trout, and thus were more likely to cause death. Lures which exhibit vigorous wobbling action when retrieved appear less likely to be deeply engulfed and consequently cause less mortality. Hooking mortality estimates for trout caught on Mepps or Cleo lures were positively and significantly correlated with size of fish. The probability of death within 48 hours of capture for heavily bleeding trout which were hooked in the gills and/or throat increased rapidly with increasing water temperature. Trout which did not bleed heavily following capture with Mepps and Cleo lures equipped with treble hooks which did not penetrate the gill or throat region were unlikely to die due to temperature effects until temperatures rose to approximately 14°C. The probability of death was not significantly associated with temperatures ranging from 5.6 to 17.8°C when trout were hooked with single pointed hooks which penetrated anatomical sites other than the gills or throat and did not bleed heavily. Present regulations on Michigan's trophy trout lakes, which restrict lures to single pointed hooks and forbid harvest of fish less than 38.1 cm, appear quite adequate to minimize losses due to hooking mortality.